Proving Hilbert’s Axioms in Tarski Geometry
نویسنده
چکیده
Hilbert’s geometry and Tarski’s geometry have the same models, since both are able to define addition and multiplication. But has anyone given explicit proofs of Hilbert’s axioms in Tarski geometry? The purpose of this note is to show that this has been done by Wanda Szmielew, by citing the specific theorems of her development that are needed. We define an explicit translation of Hilbert’s language into Tarski’s language and use Szmielew’s theorems to verify that this translation is an interpretation, i.e. takes theorems into theorems. Of course this is not an original result, but it doesn’t seem to appear explicitly in the literature and one geometer wanted to see it written out.
منابع مشابه
Tarski Geometry Axioms
This is the translation of the Mizar article containing readable Mizar proofs of some axiomatic geometry theorems formulated by the great Polish mathematician Alfred Tarski [8], and we hope to continue this work. The article is an extension and upgrading of the source code written by the first author with the help of miz3 tool; his primary goal was to use proof checkers to help teach rigorous a...
متن کاملAxiomatizing changing conceptions of the geometric continuuum II: Archimedes – Descartes –Tarski – Hilbert
In Part I of this paper we argued that the first-order systems HP5 and EG are modest complete descriptive axiomatization of most of Euclidean geometry. In this paper we discuss two further modest complete descriptive axiomatizations: Tarksi’s for Cartesian geometry and new systems for adding π. In contrast we find Hilbert’s full second order system immodest for geometrical purposes but appropri...
متن کاملOTTER Proofs in Tarskian Geometry
We report on a project to use OTTER to find proofs of the theorems in Tarskian geometry proved in Szmielew’s part (Part I) of [9]. These theorems start with fundamental properties of betweenness, and end with the development of geometric definitions of addition and multiplication that permit the representation of models of geometry as planes over Euclidean fields, or over real-closed fields in ...
متن کاملQualitative Theorem Proving in Linear Constraints
We know, from the classical work of Tarski on real closed elds, that elimination is, in principle, a fundamental engine for mechanized deduction. But, in practice, the high complexity of elimination algorithms has limited their use in the realization of mechanical theorem proving. We advocate qualitative theorem proving, where elimination is attractive since most processes of reasoning take pla...
متن کاملA Minimal Version of Hilbert’s Axioms for Plane Geometry
This note is intended to be useful to good high school students wanting a rigorous treatment of Hilbert’s axioms for plane geometry.
متن کامل